The 2025 Fantasy Football Landscape Revisited: Avoiding the Most Disappointing Picks of R1-R10

In a year marked by injuries, inconsistent performances, and unexpected breaks out, many owners who drafted players from Rounds 1-10 are left to wonder what could have been. According to Matt Okada’s exhaustive analysis, some players are particularly egregious in their failure to meet expectations. Justin Jefferson, widely regarded as one of the most talented wide receivers in the league, found himself on the list of worst picks after an underwhelming campaign that saw him average just 14 points per game. His subpar performance led many owners who drafted him in R1 to question their decision-making. Kenneth Walker III, a running back with immense upside, was another player from Rounds 1-10 who failed to live up to his potential. Despite being a workhorse for the Seahawks, he only managed to average 12 points per game, leading many owners to wonder if they should have waited until later rounds to select him. Other players, such as quarterback Kyler Murray and tight end Travis Kelce, also found themselves on the list after underperforming in critical games. In contrast, players like Cooper Kupp and Davante Adams emerged as top performers despite being drafted earlier. Matt Okada’s comprehensive analysis highlights the importance of due diligence when drafting for fantasy football. By examining past performances and injuries, owners can make more informed decisions to avoid pitfalls that have plagued many who drafted from Rounds 1-10 in 2025 drafts.